A New Theoretical Criterion to Pre-Screen Superconducting Metals
Hyunsung TNC has published a research paper on arXiv proposing a new theoretical criterion that enables the pre-experimental determination of whether a metal can become superconducting.
Title: A Modulated Electron Lattice (MEL) Criterion for Metallic Superconductivity
arXiv ID: 2601.14500v1
Publication Date: January 22, 2026
Co-authors: Researchers from University of California, Berkeley
Addressing a Fundamental Question in Superconductivity
Superconductors—materials with zero electrical resistance—are foundational to next-generation technologies, including power transmission, quantum computing, medical imaging, and precision magnetic systems.
Despite more than a century of research, superconductivity studies have largely relied on trial-and-error experiments, with no clear criterion to determine in advance whether a given metal can exhibit superconductivity.
This work directly addresses that long-standing gap.
The MEL Criterion: One Condition That Separates Possibility from Impossibility
The core contribution of the paper is the Modulated Electron Lattice (MEL) framework, which analyzes electronic structure and lattice response jointly in momentum space (q-space).
The study shows that superconductivity can emerge only if the electronic-lattice stiffness function satisfies the condition:
min₍q₎ α(q) < 0
When this condition is met, a modulated electronic lattice becomes stable, enabling the formation of a superconducting state.If not, superconductivity is fundamentally suppressed.
This single mathematical condition allows superconducting and non-superconducting metals to be classified within one unified framework.
Explaining Why Noble Metals Do Not Superconduct
Using the MEL Criterion, the study provides a unified explanation for why metals such as Cu, Ag, and Au do not exhibit superconductivity, even at extremely low temperatures.
Rather than relying on qualitative arguments, the MEL framework explains this behavior through the momentum-dependent structure of α(q), offering a structural and quantitative answer to a long-standing question in condensed matter physics.
A Criterion Applicable to Both Experiments and Computation
Importantly, the MEL Criterion is not limited to specific experimental data. It can be applied consistently to:
Experimental measurements
Electronic structure calculations
Phonon and lattice-dynamics simulations
This makes it a practical screening framework for evaluating large numbers of candidate materials under a single physical standard, with implications beyond superconductivity, including electronic materials design and quantum materials discovery.
Extending—Not Replacing—BCS Theory
The proposed framework does not reject conventional BCS theory.Instead, traditional BCS superconductors (e.g., Al, Sn, In, Pb) naturally appear as a special limit (q = 0) within the broader MEL framework.
This positions MEL as an extended, unifying theoretical structure, rather than a competing explanation.
Toward a Shift in Superconductivity Research
By introducing a criterion that determines whether superconductivity is possible in principle, this work suggests a shift in superconductivity research:
from experiment-driven discoverytocriterion-based pre-screening and design.
Hyunsung TNC is advancing this framework as a foundation for redefining how superconducting materials are evaluated, selected, and studied.
For more information or inquiries, please contact IR team.
